One Tree Hill What Is and What Should Never Be (Season 1, Episode 20)
TV-14
TV Episode | 41 min | Drama, Romance, Sport

Primary photo for What Is and What Should Never Be

One Tree Hill

What Is and What Should Never Be (Season 1, Episode 20)

TV-14

TV Episode | 41 min | Drama, Romance, Sport

Keith has a solicitation as auto-shop teacher in a Charleston school; Lucas is heartbroken his surrogate father may move that far away. Haley and Nathan finally feel cozy living together, but when Dan finds out he sold the car he gave his ...See moreKeith has a solicitation as auto-shop teacher in a Charleston school; Lucas is heartbroken his surrogate father may move that far away. Haley and Nathan finally feel cozy living together, but when Dan finds out he sold the car he gave his poor son, he demands the money it fetched unless he moves in with him again- so the kid chooses to stay poor and takes a lousy job serving food in the mall, where a kid he never even noticed in his history class is now the sports heroes' vindictive boss- one visit by Dan convinces even him to go easy on the long-envied golden boy whose silver spoon came at such a price, so he won't miss his own housewarming party. When he gets there, Mouths music and Nikki literally fighting with Peyton have alerted the police, so Dan -who just got in bed with Deb- gets a call from the sheriff to bail him out. Written by KGF Vissers See less

Contacts

+ Add

Become a member to see contact information for What Is and What Should Never Be.

Cast	+ Add Cast
24 cast members

Name	Known for
Chad Michael Murray Lucas Scott Lucas Scott See fewer	One Tree Hill (2003)
James Lafferty Nathan Scott Nathan Scott See fewer	Everyone Is Doing Great (2018)
Hilarie Burton Morgan Peyton Sawyer (as Hilarie Burton) Peyton Sawyer (as Hilarie Burton) See fewer	One Tree Hill (2003)
Bethany Joy Lenz Haley James Haley James See fewer	Dexter (2006)
Paul Johansson Dan Scott Dan Scott See fewer	One Tree Hill (2003)
Sophia Bush Brooke Davis Brooke Davis See fewer	John Tucker Must Die (2006)
Barry Corbin Whitey Whitey See fewer	Tulsa King (2022)
Craig Sheffer Keith Scott Keith Scott See fewer	A River Runs Through It (1992)
Moira Kelly Karen Roe Karen Roe See fewer	One Tree Hill (2003)
Barbara Alyn Woods Deb Scott Deb Scott See fewer	One Tree Hill (2003)
Emmanuelle Vaugier Nicki Nicki See fewer	Saw II (2005)
Blake Bashoff Gary Matheson Gary Matheson See fewer	Big Bully (1996)
Lee Norris Mouth Mouth See fewer	Zodiac (2007)
Brett Claywell Tim Tim See fewer	One Tree Hill (2003)
Mike Pniewski Mr. Carlson Mr. Carlson See fewer	Hightown (2020)
Dean James Bartender Bartender See fewer	New Best Friend (2002)
Adam Heffernan College Guy College Guy See fewer	One Tree Hill (2003)
Bobby Tyson Cop Cop See fewer	One Tree Hill (2003)
Drake Johnson Party Kid Party Kid See fewer	One Tree Hill (2003)
Leigh Jones Popular Girl Popular Girl See fewer	American Primitive (2004)
Richard Bryant Stoner #1 Stoner #1 See fewer	Vanished (I) (2014)
Dan Cox Customer Customer See fewer	Talladega Nights: The Ballad of Ricky Bobby (2006)
Jennifer Owens Cop #2 Cop #2 See fewer	One Tree Hill (2003)
Ryan Kowalske Stoner #2 Stoner #2 See fewer	Remember the Titans (2000)