J Sheekey

We would never usually point anyone in the direction of the West End on a weekday at 7pm, but as soon as you step into J Sheekey on St Martin’s Court, the hive of tourists buzzing around outside becomes a distant memory. This seafood restaurant feels a bit like a time capsule, transporting you to a glamorous, understated place where crisp white tablecloths are the height of fanciness, people wear ties to dinner, and you might spot the occasional famous face. There are rich walnut walls and deep green sofas, and although there are multiple rooms, it’s a narrow-feeling spot, so once you’re sitting in one of the corner seats, you’re locked in for the evening. 

The service is pristine, with staff accommodating theatre-goers with a speedy bill, while offering refills of the free bread to people who are settling in. And pretty much everything on the menu is a safe bet. Whether that’s thick, buttery scallops, or fried haddock and chips, J Sheekey knows what it’s doing. It’s proper without feeling too fancy, and the food is good enough that we’d fight those West End crowds for a table here.

photo credit: Karolina Wiercigroch

Food Rundown

photo credit: Rianne Shlebak

Spicy Tuna & Avocado Tartare

This tuna tartare has a nice spicy kick to it, and the layer of avocado gives it a lovely, creamy texture.

photo credit: Rianne Shlebak

Lobster & Gruyère Croquettes

Gruyère and lobster meat go well together, despite some saying you should never mix seafood and cheese. But would we rush to re-order these croquettes? There’s nothing too memorable going on, so probably not.

photo credit: Karolina Wiercigroch

J.Sheekey's Fish Pie

The oozing, brown breadcrumb and parmesan crust is one of the most comforting things we’ve eaten since discovering you can successfully dip Bahlsen Choco Leibniz in cups of tea. But the smoked fish is what makes it. That and the creamy mashed potato lid that makes every bite moreish and satisfying.

photo credit: Rianne Shlebak

Fried Fillet Of Haddock

This big piece of haddock is golden and crispy, the bed of mushy peas underneath adds some lightness to it, and the thick fluffy chips are objectively perfect. Oh, and it’s important to incorporate the tangy tartar sauce in every bite.

Goan Monkfish & Tiger Prawn Curry

A rich, tomato curry filled with soft chunks of monkfish and meaty prawns, this is one of our favourite things to order.